I'm not sure how you and John feel about contemporary furniture. I love this red chair chair and footstool but I know this might be too modern for you. I keep thinking how you said John sits in the brown chair to watch TV. It must be hard for him to find chairs that feel comfortable. A chair of this type-not the old-school recliners would be good for TV watching. There are other sleeker style recliners available if you want to consider this type of chair. Even a comfy larger upholstered chair with ottoman would be good for him.